Crystal Temptations Recalls Chocolatey Eyeballs Over Undeclared Milk Allergens
Crystal Temptations has recalled its "Halloween Chocolatey Eyeballs" due to undeclared milk allergens. The product was distributed in several states, including Indiana, and sold at stores like Marshalls, TJ Maxx, and Homegoods. No illnesses have been reported, and consumers are…

Indianapolis, IN, September 1, 2026 — Crystal Temptations is voluntarily recalling its “Halloween Chocolatey Eyeballs” product because it may contain undeclared milk allergens. The presence of milk on the product’s ingredient list is not declared.
The recall affects the “Halloween Chocolatey Eyeballs” that were distributed nationwide. Consumers can identify the product by its packaging. The specific UPC or lot numbers were not provided in the available information.
The product was distributed in several states across the United States, including Indiana. Retailers that carried the affected product include Marshalls, TJ Maxx, and Homegoods.
As of the announcement, there have been no reports of allergic reactions or illnesses associated with the consumption of these chocolatey eyeballs. However, individuals with a sensitivity or allergy to milk run the risk of experiencing an allergic reaction if they consume the product.
Customers who have purchased the recalled “Halloween Chocolatey Eyeballs” are advised to not consume the product if they have a milk allergy. Consumers are instructed to either destroy the product immediately or return it to the place of purchase for a full refund. For further information or to arrange a refund, consumers can contact Crystal Temptations directly. The company’s contact details for this recall were not specified.
Story summarized from the original created by Kelly Broderick on www.wrtv.com, see more information here.